By John Shepardson
Source: San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
In Fall 2003, the San Francisco Public Utilities
Commission (SFPUC) will switch from chlorine to chloramine disinfection
for drinking water in San Mateo, Santa Clara and Alameda counties.
Chloramine, a combination of chlorine and ammonia, is considered a better
disinfectant than chlorine alone. Chloramines have been used safely in the
U.S. and Canada for many years and many Bay Area communities are
successfully using chloramine disinfection.
Why Switch to Chloramine?
Chloramine is regarded as a better disinfectant than
chlorine alone because it lasts longer in water to more effectively remove
pathogens such as bacteria and viruses. Compared to chlorine, chloramine
produces lower levels of trihalomethanes, suspected carcinogens that form
when chlorine mixes with natural organic substances in water.
What Affect will Chloramine have on Processes that Remove
Chlorine?
The SFPUC recommends reviewing your current chlorine
removal systems to assess any needed changes to remove chloramine for the
Fall 2003 conversion. A two milligram per liter chloramine level with a
chlorine to ammonia-nitrogen ratio of five to one is expected. A residual
disinfectant range of two to four milligrams per liter is forecast.
Changes in pH, temperature or turbidity are not anticipated.
Companies report adding additional activated carbon
canisters to their filtration systems or increasing chemical dosage to
remove chloramine. Monitoring your system before and after conversion will
ensure that the treated water meets your requirements.
Note that chloramine cannot be removed by boiling water,
adding salt or letting water stand in an open container.
Will Chloramine Cause Plumbing Problems?
Chloramine can cause rubber parts in plumbing systems to
deteriorate. The SFPUC refers to this issue on its Web site by stating,
"After the conversion, rubber parts on some household plumbing and water
heaters may degrade faster than previously experienced. When replacing
rubber plumbing parts, ask for chloramine-resistant parts, which are
readily available. Plumbing and hardware supply stores and plumbers will
be able to provide further information."
Will Chloramine Harm Pet Fish or Amphibians?
Chloraminated water can harm fish and amphibians, such as
turtles and frogs. To protect fish and amphibians, remove chloramine from
water by using inexpensive water treatment products (available as drops or
tablets) or specified carbon filters. These products are readily available
at most pet supply stores and aquarium dealers.
Web resources for fish and amphibian-related information:
• http://www.sfaquarium.org
• http://www.sfbakc.org
• http://www.aquariacentral.com
How might Chloramine Affect Dialysis Patients and
Providers?
Like chlorine, chloramine can harm kidney dialysis
patients during the dialysis process if the chloramine is not removed from
water before entering the bloodstream. It is safe for dialysis patients to
drink chloraminated water because the digestive process neutralizes
chloramine before it enters the bloodstream. For further information,
contact your dialysis provider or the Trans Pacific Renal Network at (415)
472-8590 or http://www.network17.org.
Need More Information?
The SFPUC can answer your questions about the chloramine
disinfection change.
For additional information, see:
http://better.sfwater.org/ or
call the Chloramine Information Line at (415) 351-4200